The Harman Firm is proud to report that on February 12, 2018, Judge Vernon S. Broderick of the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York denied summary judgment in Umanzor v. New York City Police Department. The court’s decision allows the disability discrimination claims brought against the New York City Police Department (NYPD) by plaintiff Randy Umanzor, who is represented by The Harman Firm, LLP, to proceed to trial.
In May 2013, Mr. Umanzor was diagnosed with multiple sclerosis (MS) after experiencing symptoms of weakness and numbness. After his diagnosis, Mr. Umanzor began a treatment regimen, including a prescribed steroid medication and Vitamin B12 injections, but continued to experience some minor MS-related symptoms, like tingling, numbness, and fatigue. Mr. Umanzor applied to join the NYPD’s Police Cadet Corps in February 2014, after being diagnosed with and treated for MS. He passed the physical examination with flying colors.
However, after Mr. Umanzor disclosed his MS diagnosis during the application process, the NYPD placed him “on review.” Mr. Umanzor provided the NYPD with his medical records—which were unintentionally incomplete—and a note from his neurologist, confirming that Mr. Umanzor was “medically stable” to join the NYPD and that his neurological exam was “normal except for mild sensory loss in the first two fingers on the left hand.” After receiving these documents, the NYPD disqualified Mr. Umanzor based on the “brief period of time that had elapsed between his MS diagnosis and the date that he applied to the Police Cadet Corps.”